EDITORIAL

Danger ahead

Posted on April 16, 2010 | View 461 | Comment : 24

March Inflation Needs Policy Response

As was widely expected, inflation measured by the wholesale price index (WPI) has inched up from the February level of 9.89% to 9.90% in March 2010. True, it is a whisker short of the dreaded 10% mark. But that is small comfort. At 9.9%, inflation is not only well above the RBI’s target of 8.5% for March-end but is also well above the comfort zone for any democratically-elected government. More to the point, while food inflation shows scant signs of abating, inflation in manufactured products (7.13%) and fuel and power (12.71%) is now significantly higher than a year ago. Thus, the contribution of non-food inflation to overall inflation is now almost 50% up from almost zero a few months ago. This clearly calls for action. While the RBI is expected to tighten its monetary policy stance in its policy statement due next week, monetary policy alone cannot win the battle against inflation. The government must do its bit to remove supply constraints (read offload more from its buffer stocks) and at the same time exit more aggressively from its excessively accommodative fiscal stance.
    
As there are no elections, barring assembly elections in Bihar this year, the government may not have to face a wrathful public (and that, perhaps, explains some of the lethargy on its part in tackling inflation). It might also be able to deflect some criticism on the grounds that containing inflation is the responsibility of the states, rather than the Centre. But that will not wash. While combating inflation is the joint responsibility of the Centre and the states, the latter can at best play a supporting role, say, by ensuring a more efficient public distribution system. In contrast, fiscal and, to a lesser extent, monetary policy, both of which have a major role in determining the overall demand-supply balance in an economy, lie squarely in the Centre’s domain. Whatever the justification for an easy policy stance earlier, the situation is vastly different today. February’s 15%-plus industrial growth is only the latest in a fairly impressive list of indicators suggesting growth is now back on track, inflation isn’t. The Centre would do well to heed that warning.

Post Comment

Comment

Comments (24)

  • Dear Sirs, I feel the root cause of inflation is (i) black money lying in cash with all and sundary in power and ruling India (ii) the black money abroad (iii) black money in benami properties.(iv) black money in cash transactions in all the business dealings (iv) National character and national feeling is completely missing in India (v) For economic reasons every Indian criticizes the politicians/bureaucrats etc but what his his(her) own contribution as a Citizen of India. It is only My/me factor and the word we as Indian is missing. Each citizen irrespective caste creed and religion has to rise to the occasion and take a lead. Unless we find out a solution to this problem no problem can be solved.

    Posted by Harish Kumar | 24 Apr, 2010

  • india is big nation in terms of population but at the same time india has also emarged as big producer in agricultire but still lot is to be done while framing the agriculture policies as this is important sector because 70% of population depends upon it and while framing it govt has to be very strict in laws which in alter can reduce the infllation. but our populatuion is main cause of unwanted inflation. we have to fulfil their basic need so that people dont go for dumping due to uncertanity which is the basic cause for inflation.

    Posted by pardeep singh kala , ISD HEAD KASHMIR at SBI-MF | 23 Apr, 2010

  • Hi I am conducting a program on Forex & Treasury Management. People interested may contact
    http://www.iicm.in/certificate-forex-treasury-management-0

    Posted by NIJAY GUPTA , Faculty at N.K. GUPTA & CO | 19 Apr, 2010

  • you may give all powers to Prime Minister or Ruling Party Chief or RBI Governor or Prakash Karat or the Ghost or Chairman Mao or the Greatest economists of the World. But none can stop the inflation that we are currently experiencing due to past policies of government, its extravagance and incompetence and the corrupt, irresponsible behavior of politicians. What the most powerful person can do is to try to see that inflation does not rise again after it comes down on its own in another few months or the current inflation rate is not stoked further by mismanagement of the economy.
    Do not have blind belief in the powers of governments and human beings in avoiding inflation that is happening due to past events. Waht the powerful people can do is to do something now correctly to ...See More

    Posted by Basudeb Sen | 18 Apr, 2010

  • I quote from the Eco Survey 2010 by GoI -"As of now, the outlook for inflation is conditioned by supply-side pressures in the near term, possible return of pricing power with stronger recovery in growth,further revival in private demand with improving consumer and business confidence, and possible spurt in global commodity prices in response to recovery in advanced economies. While the fiscal issues including fiscal rectitude are important, the transmission of the monetary policy stance to the monetary and real sectors is equally critical. It would therefore also be incumbent on the policy authorities not only to address the inflationary expectations but also monitor and ensure that the growth in money supply and credit to productive sectors is at the envisaged levels so that the growth ...See More

    Posted by Abhyuday Chowdhury,Partner at practising CA|18 Apr, 2010

  • Our nation is suffering from many ills and much more than other nations if one likes to compare. It is quite shameful to list them down here and I would not like to do that. We talk, discuss, hold seminars only to revisit these issues. Our inflation is a resultant of gross level of corruption in all walks of society. We are corrupt in policy formulation, implementation and even data collection. Pecuniary greed, acts to acquire status higher than ability, create hegemony, the know all syndrome etc is killing each one of us daily and pushing harder towards the ill-fated end?. The question is can I do? The answer is murder of IIT engineer Satyendra Dubey and many more. So. who can and has the power to act? It is not me you or we, it is the most powerful person in the country, yes you got it ...See More

    Posted by Awni Ranjan , Consultant at Freelancer | 18 Apr, 2010

  • I have just received a message and a call from my friend that why you are not writing on such a burning issue, but since this is purely political issue I was not wanting to write but frienship matters a lot and we have to sacrifice many things for it.
    All Govt. Depts should work in harmony and with sincere efforts to control their Ministeries but should not work as if they are allies only looking after specific Ministeries without answerability, whereas they are answerable and should sincerely think what a bad reputation it is giving to the party in Power (Do not think Congress only but also to OPPOSITION because they too have responsiblity to the people.

    Regards,

    PRADEEP AGARWAL
    FCA, LLB, DISA


    Posted by PRADEEP AGARWAL , HOF(W) at ACIL | 18 Apr, 2010

  • I know if I will write I will write bluntly, whether accepatable to your paper or not, because due to bluntness I have virtually ceased writing because bluntness/crudeness can go against the Govt, also, which I feel might not be acceptable to your paper whatever the case may be.

    Regards,

    PRADEEP AGARWAL
    FCA, LLB, DISA

    Posted by PRADEEP AGARWAL , HOF(W) at ACIL | 18 Apr, 2010

  • The inflation is now high mainly because of the base effect. The Government has to do something to arrest the prices like better supply side management. RBI may also do its bit. But, already, the tightening by RBI in last few months has resulted in India being the rare economy withdrawing all the real fiscal and monetary stimulus for the economy. After the impact of global recession , the economy has just started breathing normally. We expect high growth rate as well as better emplyment figures in 2010-11. But, these are only expectations and not the reality yet. It would be better to permit the economy to grow for one more year or at least not hit it hard till other economies/countries are also tightening at least as much as India has already done.
    This is essential to make Indian ...See More

    Posted by KAUSHAL KISHORE,ASSISTANT GENERAL MANAGER at National Bank For Agriculture And Rural Development|17 Apr, 2010

  • RBI can not bring any changes in the Repo, Reverse Repo and CRR to contain inflation. These are corporate managed/advised.
    Inflation is a chain reaction due to Petroleum products’ price rise. The OIL companies should be delinked from publishing Balance Sheets. Let them incur loss as the benefit goes to the Indian Public only.

    Posted by Narayan swamy Krishnan,|17 Apr, 2010

  • I agree with the comment posted by Mr. Sujeet Sinha that RBI has a minute role to play in tackling inflation . As per statstistics 60% of the food produce in India rot due to improper supply chain management . Its not the question of getting our lands more productive but government needs to improve its supply chain as well as brokers in between the supply chain . If this can be done india is producing enough food to cater the needs of Indians and can tackle food inflation .

    Posted by Ashish Shanker , Sales Manager at Indiabulls Financial Services Ltd. | 17 Apr, 2010

  • Yes definitely the government has to take some quick actions and stop the lobbying of food and agricultural goods ...
    India is a common mans place ......so let things be affordable for us and we can buy basic things required

    Posted by shab | 17 Apr, 2010

  • yes this government should come up , and do resolve the matter soon. I am a comman man can only servivve then only when gov is on strong acction

    Posted by amit sarkar , mba at -------------- | 17 Apr, 2010

  • I think the 3 Idiots viz Montek Singh, C. Rangarajan & Pranab Mukherjee are fooling the 125 crore people of country/India by talking of growth which is not relevant with over 25% over inflation in the country. Even their talking growth/GDP story of 8% and WPI 10%, there is a negative growth of 2%. I think its time for the people to wake up and topple this government. I wish Rahul Gandhi could understand their (3 idiots) political interest and could do something on inflation.

    The govt./press is more worried about unemployment of US, Obama taking his family for dinner or Tiger Wood's affairs, than for the unemployment, population and inflation issues facing the country.

    Posted by NIJAY GUPTA , CONSULTANT at N.K. GUPTA & CO | 17 Apr, 2010

  • The belief that any Govt. can control a inflation in full force is unscientific and wishful thinking. Govt's can contribute to future or excerberate a inflation in fullswing: it can never curb inflation in force that has resulted from external factors beyond Government's control and/ or Govt's own policy mistakes in the past. Even if Govt/ RBI does not take any anti-inflationary measures, current inflation will itself correct iot as demand-supply forces will automatically remove the imbalaces. But still govt./ RBI can take anti-inflationary policies now to reduce the likelihood of inflation rising again in future, but such measures will increase the period of current inflation as tighter monetary policy can onlu hurt short-term supply situation and raise costs.
    There is no ...See More

    Posted by Basudeb Sen | 16 Apr, 2010

  • Inflation is more about demand supply and relatively lesser to do with RBI Monitory policy . We should look at our agriculture sector . Our per hectare productivity among lowest in world . this sector has potential to take care of so many of our problems .we can curtail food inflation , increase employement , exports to grow .

    Posted by Sujeet Sinha , Asst Vice President at Citifinancial India | 16 Apr, 2010

  • Unless: (i)we start mechanical and modern agriculture methods,(ii) lay more stress full utilization of agricultural land (iii) right price to farmer,(iv) more agricultural proceeds be exported (v) more small scale industry (vi) more and more industrialization of India (vii)increase exports (viii) It is right time RBI should intervene and rupee must depreciate against all the currencies for increase in exports (ix) Black money abroad/India to be brought into banks in India (x) above all a political will to do that. Inflation cannot be controlled.

    Posted by Harish Kumar , CEO at Checkdeals | 16 Apr, 2010

  • Inflation rate with all its uncertainties will continue to be one of the much critcised performance indices of Indian economy. We donot have any control on agriculture(it is god we believe in), We have little control over oil prices(it is oil gods we pray to), we donot have any political will to curb parallel economy of so called black money( they are pretty well invested back in the main stream economy) and still we like to search for a logical face of inflation. Govt of India does not have full data to control inflation, thats for sure. Take for example the loksabha election year or any election for that matter. For loksabha if we take 6 persons fighting for each seat then we have 3258 persons for 543 seats(+/-) in loksabha. Each spending Rs 1500000/- then the total spending comes to Rs ...See More

    Posted by Abhyuday Chowdhury,Partner at practising CA|16 Apr, 2010

  • Irrespective of whatever policy the Government or the RBI takes now or in the near future, there is no way for inflation to come down in the next few months. The rise in inflation to 9.9% now is the result of policies and agricultural crop failure of the past year. Even if the Govt. or the RBI does nothing in the next three months inflation will not ease gradually over the next 6 months, unless of course there is another serious crop failure or natural diaster.
    Despite that however there is urgent need for Government to reduce fiscal deficit, reduce wasteful expenditure, remove barriers in infrastructure, reform agriculture for private sector ivestment in agriculture through sale of agricultural land held by small and marginal absentee landowners, incentives for large-sclae ...See More

    Posted by Basudeb Sen,Independent Director at South Asian Petrochem Ltd|16 Apr, 2010

  • In my opinion, contribution of Black Money in circulation in the country has to be checked and unearthed. For this, the Govt. must do whatever necessary.

    Posted by S, RAVI SHANKAR , Accounts Officer at WIRTGEN | 16 Apr, 2010

  • In order to contain supply constraints, which is one of the major contributor to inflat inflation, extra efforts in public interest have to be launched by the Governmental machinery through seizure of stock accummulated by the hoarders and speculators. I am sure this would impact downsizing inflation by at least 2-3 percantage points. In fact horders are also to be treated on the pattern of naxal/underworld ailment.
    2. Mass education needs be spread to make the peolple at large know that they can contribute in nation building by keeping their demand at low level when ever there is supply side shortage due to natural calamity or artificial creation.

    Posted by Jagdish Kumar Kanojia | 16 Apr, 2010

  • Yes govenmnet should take quick action to control inflation.

    Posted by PRASENJIT CHAUDHURI,Junior Accountant cum fund Administration Coordinator at SRD Cell, WBSRDA, A Govt Department in W.B. of Panchyat and Rural Development|16 Apr, 2010

  • As the government may not have to face a public in comming days, Goverment should tighten its monetary policy, to control the inflation.

    Posted by prashant kulkarni | 16 Apr, 2010

  • The Inflation rate should be ideally below 5 percent. Now we are almost double of it. Food prices (WPI) has gone up drastically making the life miserable of common people. Apart the salary deductions and job cuts added to the woes of severe recession. Government and our planning commission should come out with effective fiscal measures to have better control over inflation.

    Posted by Ranganath K Naik , Regional Accountant Maharashtra at Aga Khan Education Service India Mazagaon Mumbai | 16 Apr, 2010

User Picture India one of the best recyclers in the world The green technology space is hotting up in India and private equity funds are getting excited about.. Vivek Tandon General Partner, Aloe Private Equity Read full story

User Picture No time for trade war Pushing China into revaluing its currency risks toppling the global recovery from its stabilising ax.. Joseph E Stiglitz Read full story

User Picture Doha Round at the crossroads The negotiations have clearly waned in ambition since the Hong Kong meet and are still in ‘int.. Pradeep S Mehta Read full story

Strategy & Architectural Knowledge

Carliss Baldwin

This paper describes how entrepreneurial firms can use superior architectural knowledge of a technic..

Read full story

A continual flight from wonder

Mukul Sharma

In his Critique of Practical Reason, the philosopher Immanuel Kant named the two things that filled ..

Read full story

User Picture Rajiv Luthra's advice to startups The negotiations have clearly waned in ambition since the Hong Kong meet and are still in ‘int.. Rajiv K Luthra Managing Partner, Luthra & Luthra Law Offices Read full story
The Economy Times

About Us | Terms & Conditions | Contact Us

Copyright © PeerPower.com 2010. All rights reserved.

powered by PeerPower